Years
after Bill Stein came out to friends and colleagues, he moved near family
in
Oregon
and went back into hiding.
If
someone at his
Portland
retirement home makes an anti-gay slur, Stein, 86, says nothing.
"I'm,
by nature, chicken," the retired anthropology professor said. "
If you don't say 'I'm gay,' you pass. I'm pretty well closeted."
On
Valentine's Day, Stein drove to
Gresham
to visit Rainbow Vista, one of the first retirement homes in the nation
marketed to gay seniors. After a lunch of spaghetti with heart-shaped
garlic toast, he played cards and chatted with the owner, the manager and
a gay couple who plan to move in this summer.
But
the rest of the dining room was deserted, as were most apartments. Rainbow
Vista
, 10 months old, has just two tenants, both straight. They are holdovers
from the era when the building was marketed to the mainstream.
Nationwide,
dozens of groups have tried to build retirement communities for gay,
lesbian, bisexual and transgendered people. So far, only three have
opened, said Gerard Koskovich, who tracks the subject for the Lesbian and
Gay Aging Issues Network.
Aging
experts, entrepreneurs and nonprofit groups say the need is there, but the
challenge is more complex than if-you-build-it-they-will-come: raising
money; finding an affordable, attractive and gay-friendly locale;
motivating people who -- like all senior citizens -- might want or need
anything from Pilates classes to nursing care.
So
far, "there hasn't been the interest and demand I expected. . . . I
don't really care," said Rainbow Vista owner Henry Moshberger, 65,
adding that he'll persist. "This is where I'm living. Basically, I
bought a retirement home for myself and all my friends."
The
push for housing stems mostly from gay baby boomers. More open than
previous generations, they don't expect to hide as they age. But in a 2006
poll, fewer than half had confidence that health care professionals would
treat them with respect as they grow older.
In
the past decade, communities have brought forward at least 40 ideas for
gay senior housing, but many stalled in the planning. So far, an upscale
project in
Santa Fe
that opened in 2006 has had difficulty filling. An affordable complex that
opened in 2007 in
Hollywood
,
Calif.
, has had more success.
Unlike those, Rainbow
Vista didn't emerge from market surveys or social service work -- just the
drive of a single entrepreneur. An
Oregon
native, Moshberger lived in
California
, where he bought and sold real estate.
In mid-2005, he needed an
investment to avoid big taxes on proceeds from another sale. The former
Camlu Retirement Apartments, with its bright views of Mount Hood, had sat
vacant for several years before Moshberger spotted it on visits to his
sister's
Gresham
condo.
"I probably shouldn't
admit this," he said, but he bought the building for just more than
$1 million without ever looking inside.
It's one of several
cookie-cutter nursing homes built in the 1970s. While cheerfully
redecorated, its age shows in modestly sized apartments, tiny bathrooms
and individual "kitchens" that consist of a microwave and
refrigerator. The building boasts an impressive commercial kitchen, but
there aren't enough residents to justify daily meal service.
Camlu's nursing license
had expired, and Moshberger wasn't interested in entering such a highly
regulated field. With his sister as manager, he decided to pitch the new
Autumn
Park
as a building for active senior citizens.
It didn't work. By June of
last year, Moshberger changed plans, establishing a nonprofit and
rechristening the building Rainbow Vista with a new motto: "
A Place
of Our Own."
Moshberger knew about discrimination. Ten years ago, he left a
senior citizens mobile home park in
California
after someone saw him kissing a male friend on his front porch. Formerly
friendly neighbors froze him out as managers nitpicked his yard and patio.
"Younger people, when you tell them what we're doing (at
Rainbow Vista), they say, 'Why would you need to do that?' They don't see
the problem," Moshberger said. "In their age group, there isn't
that discrimination. In my age group, there is."
A couple of months ago, he hired manager Ian Jones, a certified
nursing assistant with a degree in health care administration. Jones has
years of experience in caring for senior citizens and hopes Rainbow Vista
ultimately will expand its services.
Donald Bramley, 70, and
Howard Turner, 67, are decorating a double studio apartment and plan to
move in July.
At the Valentine's party, they played with Jones' green-cheeked
conure, the backs of their hands touching as the bird scrambled from one
set of fingers to the next.
"If you're not gay, you don't understand the needs . . . to
talk to people, and just be totally relaxed and not have to watch what
you're saying," Turner said. "It makes life much simpler."
Stein chatted with them about travel, teaching and his books on
Peruvian anthropology. He hopes to move this spring.
"The more I come out here, the more unhappy I am in the
situation I've got," he said. "I'm free here."
More Information on US Elder Rights Issues