Studies of the Infirmities of Aging Dogs Offer Insights
for Humans
By: Jane E. Brody
New York Times, February 5, 2002
Having an old dog is akin to having a newborn baby,
only worse. Babies, at least, become easier to care for and more fun to be
with as they get older. The dog gets harder and less amusing. No owner can
get a continuous night's sleep when every whimper may be an announcement
that the dog, no longer continent, needs to go out in a hurry.
New babies remain confined to cradle or crib and
rarely rustle the bedding. But owners of old pets are often awakened by
nighttime pacing and the click, click, click of nails on the floor, or by
the painful yelp of an arthritic dog trying to lie down.
And while caring for an old pet gets harder, the
rewards decline as it becomes increasingly unresponsive and immobile. Loss
of hearing keeps a sleeping pet (and they do sleep most of the day) from
noticing its owner's return and bestowing a loving greeting. Arthritis
turns a walk into a crawl and forces many owners to carry their dogs up
and down stairs and lift them into cars.
An aging animal's interests are likely to wane —
even favorite toys are often ignored — and memory fades, as well, with
some dogs forgetting whether to go through a door on the hinge side or the
knob side.
Hearing a description of these symptoms, an older
friend remarked, "So how is this different from an elderly
person?" And indeed, scientists who study canine brain aging have
found many close parallels to the human experience, close enough to
warrant research financing from the National Institute on Aging.
And happily for older people as well as for pet
owners, scientific studies in dogs strongly suggest that some of the more
debilitating effects of age on the brain may be averted or at least eased
by consuming more substances that protect the brain's cellular mechanisms
from the ravages of oxidation.
Dr. Norton W. Milgram, a behavioral neuroscientist at
the University of Toronto, and Dr. Carl W. Cotman, a neurochemist in the
Institute for Brain Aging and Dementia at the University of California at
Irvine, have been studying old dogs as models of human aging.
"It has become clear as we've looked at how
cognitive changes occur over time," Dr. Milgram said, "that
antioxidants are the best suggestion of a possibly useful intervention,
because the evidence indicates that oxidative stress is the main factor in
brain aging."
Dr. Cotman agreed. "Oxidative damage is a key
feature in the aged brains of animals and people," he said, "and
the brains of individuals with Alzheimer's disease show greater
damage."
He suggested that antioxidant supplements like
vitamins E and C might "improve cognitive function and reduce
age-associated cognitive decline" in people as well as in pets, since
dogs, as they grow older, develop the same pathological changes in the
brain as aged people.
Clinical trials testing the value of antioxidants in
treating Alzheimer's are under way. In one completed study, vitamin E
supplements delayed the need for institutionalization among moderately to
severely demented people, Dr. Cotman found.
Dr. Barbara Shukitt-Hale, a research psychologist at
the Department of Agriculture's Human Nutrition Research Center on Aging
at Tufts University, is among those who have demonstrated benefits in an
antioxidant-enriched diet for the aging mammalian brain. By feeding
extracts of blueberries, strawberries and spinach to rats, she has found
that "we can stall or even reverse the effects of aging on the brain,
both behaviorally and chemically."
She added, "It's very plausible that
antioxidant-rich diets would also help older dogs." As for people,
she said, "we all should be doing this — eating at least five
servings of fruits and vegetables a day to forestall or even improve the
effects of aging."
Pet food companies and producers of animal
pharmaceuticals have taken a strong interest in the research. Dr. Milgram
said at least one company, Hill's Pet Nutrition, had formulated an
antioxidant-rich food associated with significant improvement in canine
brain function in well-designed studies in both the laboratory and the
homes of older dogs. The studies were jointly supported by the company,
the National Institute on Aging and the United States military.
These studies, and the background research supporting
them, were described last month at a symposium on brain aging in dogs
sponsored by Hill's in conjunction with the annual meeting of the North
American Veterinary Association in Orlando, Fla.
For many reasons, the brain is highly vulnerable to
oxidative damage. It is loaded with polyunsaturated fats, which are easily
attacked by oxidizing agents. The brain is a metabolic powerhouse that
uses as much as 20 percent of the body's oxygen supply.
The oxygen, in turn, generates free radicals, highly
reactive chemical fragments that can damage the membranes of cells, making
them leaky and vulnerable to toxic agents. The free radicals can also
destroy critical cellular ingredients like DNA and enzymes, including the
enzymes needed to process metabolic debris.
Under the stress of oxidation, synapses that enable
brain cells to communicate with one another are lost, and there is a
buildup of a toxic peptide called beta amyloid, resulting in brain cell
dysfunction. Yet the brain has relatively low levels of antioxidant
enzymes to protect it from free-radical damage. And unlike other organs,
it cannot repair itself from oxidative damage.
Yet as with people, some of whom remain mentally
sound into their 90's and beyond, the brains of some old dogs continue to
function well, which suggests that it may be possible to improve the fates
of those that do not.
Working with a colony of 48 beagles, ages 9 to 14
owned by the military, Dr. Milgram and his colleagues spent a year
studying their cognitive function, then divided the animals into four
groups that were cognitively equal.
Two groups were fed the antioxidant-rich dog food,
now marketed by Hill's as Canine b/d, and the other two were fed an
ordinary supermarket food that looked identical. One group in each of the
two diet categories also received "cognitive enrichment": five
to six days a week they were given puzzles like finding hidden food
rewards. At the end of a year, the four groups were retested for cognitive
function. The group that had both the antioxidant-rich food and the
enrichment scored significantly higher than the other groups.
Dr. Milgram concluded while the animals receiving the
fortified food performed better than the others, the special diet was most
effective when combined with mental stimulation, which owners naturally
provide for their pets by playing with them, walking them, talking to them
and petting them.
In a similar study in the homes of older dogs, those
receiving the antioxidant-rich diet also did significantly better on
cognitive tests, with differences showing up in some cases in as little as
a month, said Dr. Gary Landsberg, a veterinary behaviorist in Thornhill,
Ontario.
The special diet, formulated as a dry dog food,
contains antioxidant- rich fruits and vegetables, vitamins E and C, the
fatty acids DHA and EPA, carnitine and alpha lipoic acid, which helps to
promote the health of mitochondria, the powerhouses of cells, Dr.
Landsberg said.
Dr. Landsberg lamented that most pet owners waited
too long to bring age-related behavioral changes to the attention of their
vets, since preventing cognitive decline is preferable to trying to slow
or reverse it.
"The effects of brain aging can be subtle and
progress slowly, which makes them difficult to detect," he noted.
"Dogs are typically more than 11 years old when owners first detect
clinical signs of cognitive dysfunction syndrome. However, in the
laboratory, we can often see subtle changes in cognitive function at 8, 9
or 10."
There are also differences in breeds and in the
demands placed on the animals, with early signs of brain impairment more
obvious in dogs trained to perform tasks, like assisting people who are
blind or hard of hearing. An estimated 10 million dogs in the United
States are at ages that render them vulnerable to cognitive dysfunction.
"Owners should start looking at their pets for
early signs of brain aging," Dr. Landsberg said. "Does the dog
recognize people, places and pets it knows and greet you in the same way?
Does it remember previously learned behaviors, like house- training? Has
it acquired new fears and anxieties?"
The hallmarks of brain aging in dogs are summarized
by the acronym DISH — disorientation; interaction changes; sleep or
activity changes; and house-training is forgotten.
If any such behavioral changes are noted, Dr.
Landsberg said, the first step is to have the animal fully examined by a
veterinarian for a treatable underlying health problem, like thyroid,
kidney or adrenal gland disease, that may cause symptoms that mimic those
of cognitive decline. Behavioral changes could also be a result of
arthritis or of failing hearing or vision or of changes in the environment
like the arrival of a new pet or baby, marriage, divorce or a new home or
schedule.
"Many owners fail to discuss geriatric-onset
behavioral changes with their veterinarians because they incorrectly
assume that these problems are an unfortunate and untreatable result of
age," Dr. Landsberg told the Orlando symposium. Testing old dogs that
may seem to the owner and the vet to be clinically healthy, he said, often
reveals undiagnosed medical problems at earlier and more treatable stages.
FAIR USE NOTICE: This
page contains copyrighted material the use of which has not been
specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Global Action on Aging
distributes this material without profit to those who have expressed a
prior interest in receiving the included information for research and
educational purposes. We believe this constitutes a fair use of any such
copyrighted material as provided for in 17 U.S.C § 107. If you wish to
use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go
beyond fair use, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
|