Picture
Credit: Obama bubble by Greg Groesch for The
Washington Times.
As if the housing market collapse and European debt
crisis weren’t bad enough, another fiscal disaster
looms on the horizon. New rules adopted last week by
the Governmental Accounting Standards Board (GASB)
clarify the depth of mismanagement of state and local
government pension programs. When the bills come due,
it’s going to be very, very expensive.
The Pew Center reports a $1.38 trillion gap between
the assets states have set aside to fund retirement
and health care programs compared to the amount of
their obligations to retirees. The revised accounting
standards will show the true gap is even wider -
something that could trigger a round of downgrades by
rating agencies.
The problem is, state and local politicians always
find it easier to make lavish promises than to back up
their commitments with proper funding. Without
immediate and significant reform, many other
governments are going to find themselves filing for
Chapter 9 bankruptcy, just as the city of Stockton,
Calif., did on Tuesday.
The Pew Center says states may be able to meet
immediate obligations, but as of 2010, Wisconsin had
the only fully-funded program. A decade ago, more than
half of state government pensions were properly
funded. The worst offenders were Connecticut,
Illinois, Kentucky and Rhode Island, with less than 55
percent of obligations covered. Maryland funded only
64 percent of its liability. Virginia did slightly
better at 72 percent, but even that is well below 80
percent funding necessary for a pension system to be
considered healthy.
The situation looks more dire using the updated
accounting standards. Governments with larger
shortfalls in their pension funds will be required to
factor in the probability that they will have to
borrow to meet their obligations to retirees. Plans
currently are using an 8 percent discount rate when
calculating the value of future obligations. Already
underfunded programs will have to cut that to 3 or 4
percent under the new rules, which means their books
will reflect even more red ink.
The new rule is going to hit the plans with large
shortfalls particularly hard. The Center for
Retirement Research at Boston College estimated the
rule change will increase the shortfall in funding
from 76 cents on the dollar under the current rules to
57 cents, or a total increase in shortfall of about
$900 billion.
These funding gaps can’t be met without cuts in
benefits, increases in contributions or tax increases.
And even the new rules might be understating the true
extent of the liability. The correct discount rate for
pensions, arguably, is the risk-free rate for annuity,
not the average return on high-risk stocks, which many
plans will still be able to continue using.
Raising taxes on already overburdened residents isn’t
the answer to the pension problem. Politicians at
every level need to realize government must cut back
before the entire system collapses.