Home |  Elder Rights |  Health |  Pension Watch |  Rural Aging |  Armed Conflict |  Aging Watch at the UN  

  SEARCH SUBSCRIBE  
 

Mission  |  Contact Us  |  Internships  |    

 



back

 

Elderly weary of Medicare vows. A key voting bloc demands details

By Patrick Healy, the Boston Globe

October 9, 2003

SIOUX CITY , Iowa -- As Senator John F. Kerry was pressing his ongoing attack on Democratic rival Howard Dean over Medicare, 87-year-old Lula Kirk took out a pen and started doing a little math on her paper place mat in a senior citizen center's lunchroom.

Here were her calculations: $317 plus $255 in Social Security checks equals $572 to support herself per month, or $6,864 a year. Then she began subtracting: $79 per month to repay a bank loan, $146 for rent, $28 for phone service, $15 for J.C. Penney ("I owe them a lot"), $33 for medicines, $100 for food, and $33 for her monthly hairdo.

"Leaves me $138 to live on, and that's if my heart troubles or diabetes don't act up," Kirk said after Kerry's speech Tuesday in this small city in northwestern Iowa .

To her and many other elderly Iowans, who make up a powerful voting bloc in the first-in-the-nation presidential caucuses in January, the leading Democrats like Kerry and Dean have so far been speaking in abstractions: Save Medicare. Preserve Social Security. Create a prescription drug benefit for the elderly.

Their attacks on each other -- especially Kerry's and Representative Richard A. Gephardt's salvos that Dean supported deep cuts in Medicare in 1995 -- are less persuasive, or relevant, than the day-to-day, dollars-and-cents anxieties that keep many at the Siouxland Senior Center awake at night.

As the nine Democratic presidential contenders gather in Phoenix this evening for their next televised debate, Kerry and Gephardt are seeking ways to pull ahead of Dean in polls in Iowa and nationally. Those three, along with most of the other candidates, have hit on Medicare's future in particular as a rallying point to help lock up a share of the 15 percent of Iowa residents who are over the age of 65.

These Iowans tend to vote in disproportionately high numbers, according to the Iowa AARP, and could prove decisive in a tight caucus race next year.

"About 80 percent of my patients are on Medicare, and believe me, they are going to be voting next year," said Diane Marshall, a respiratory therapist at Immanuel Medical Center in Omaha who attended a Kerry speech on health care Monday at a senior citizens center in Council Bluffs, Iowa. A Kerry supporter herself, she added, "I think seniors are going to look hard at each of the candidates. They want specifics about what these men would do for them."

Some elderly Iowans say they are bewildered by recent criticisms by Kerry and Gephardt of Dean's comments, in 1995, praising a congressional Republican proposal to cut the growth of Medicare spending by $270 billion. Dean says he was supporting cost containment measures that President Clinton ultimately adopted, although Clinton 's were much less extensive. Some seniors say they are disappointed that the debate over health care today seems to be largely reduced to a Medicare battle eight years ago.

"I feel like my throat is being cut today with all the trouble I have paying for drugs," said Marilyn Gorn, a 69-year-old from Council Bluffs , who says half of her income goes to medication for a host of ailments. "The Democrats need to be saying how they'll pay for a drug benefit, right now, and how they can get a Congress of Republicans to go along."

Of Iowa 's 2.9 million residents, almost 694,000 are over the age of 55, or nearly one-quarter, according to the US census. The elderly population in Iowa has been growing faster than in many other states, according to the census and state AARP officials, and the elderly traditionally register to vote and attend the January presidential caucuses in high numbers. Iowa also has the largest percentage of residents over the age of 85 -- about 2.2 percent, or 65,000 people -- of any state.

"The political muscle of seniors here is just huge," said Scott McIntyre, a spokesman for the Iowa Hospital Association. "You don't talk about health care in Iowa without talking about seniors and Medicare."

About 450,000 Iowans, or roughly 16 percent of the population, are Medicare beneficiaries, according to the association; only Florida , Maine , Pennsylvania , and West Virginia have higher percentages of the population relying on the federal health program for the elderly and disabled. In some rural areas of Iowa , up to 80 percent of patients are on Medicare.

Campaigning in Iowa this week, Kerry proposed a new "compact with the greatest generation," promising to crack down on drug companies to lower the prices of medication by "cutting the greed out of the system," such as million-dollar salaries for company executives and legal loopholes that slow the sale of lower-cost generic drugs.

Both Gephardt and Dean have also campaigned hard on health care, with Gephardt promising a huge expansion of health care insurance to approach universal coverage, and Dean, a doctor, introducing plans to improve long-term care for the elderly and restating his support for Medicare.

Pat Lawson, a 50-year-old on state disability and Medicare for a number of medical problems, especially migraines, was eating a grilled cheese sandwich at the Council Bluffs center when Kerry spoke Monday. She said she is skeptical, too, about just how many promises a politician can deliver on.

"I think seniors are fed up. We've been hearing about a new prescription drug benefit since the Clintons were elected . . . and nothing has improved," said Lawson, who gets by on $500 per month but has drug bills that can run as high as $400 per month. "It's hard to listen to these attacks between Kerry and Dean about Medicare. I don't know if any politician can really make the system better."

 

 

 

 


Copyright © 2002 Global Action on Aging
Terms of Use  |  Privacy Policy  |  Contact Us