|
SEARCH | SUBSCRIBE | ||
|
Bacterial
Infection Kills 100 Patients at Quebec Hospital in 18 Months Sheryl
Ubelacker, CNEWS
Quebec, Canada
August
4, 2004
A bacterial agent commonly found in health-care settings has been blamed for the deaths of 100 patients in the last 18 months in a single Quebec hospital, says an infectious disease expert at the facility, who is calling for government action to forestall more outbreaks across the country. Dr. Jacques
Pepin says cases of Clostridium difficile at University Hospital in
Sherbrooke have been steadily increasing. And the incidence among those
most vulnerable to the disease - patients aged 65 and older - jumped
10-fold between 1991 and the end of 2003. The infection
has been blamed for killing 54 patients in 2003 and another 46 in the
first six months of this year at the 683-bed hospital, said Pepin, lead
author of a study in the Canadian Medical Association Journal. Using patient
records, the University of Sherbrooke researchers compiled cases of C.
difficile and deaths from the infection over the last 14 years. They found
the proportion of patients who died within 30 days of diagnosis soared to
almost 14 per cent in 2001 from less than five per cent in 1991. "A lot of
these patients were quite elderly people and for some of them, they
obviously died for other reasons," Pepin said Wednesday from
Sherbrooke, explaining that many were being treated for other serious
illnesses. "But . . . in my opinion, the vast majority of these
patients died directly of this infection." Outbreaks of C.
difficile have killed almost 90 patients at several hospitals in both
Montreal and Calgary. And more recently, a patient died of the disease in
a hospital in Newmarket, just north of Toronto. In June, Quebec's chief
medical officer ordered hospitals to record all cases of the infection so
the province can determine if the disease is actually on the rise. C. difficile is
a garden-variety bacterium in hospitals and usually poses no threat to
healthy people. But it can become dangerous for hospital patients treated
with antibiotics for other illnesses, such as pneumonia, because the drugs
kill off so-called good bacteria in the intestinal tract, allowing C.
difficile to flourish. It then begins
secreting a toxin, said Pepin. "And it is this toxin which starts
producing the symptoms." The most
obvious symptom is diarrhea, which can be so severe that some patients
lose too much fluid in their bodies and go into shock caused by plummeting
blood pressure and then die, he said. Pepin theorizes
that the C. difficile mini-epidemics may be related to a greater number of
older patients occupying hospital beds because of an aging population and
the possibility that more virulent strains of the bacterium have
developed, which produce more toxins. "It used
to be considered just something annoying. You'd get four or five loose
stools a day . . . and it wouldn't be that bad," said Pepin.
"But what we've been seeing for the last couple of years is much more
severe diarrhea. So if you have 15 or 20 bowel movements a day," the
chance of it spreading from patient to patient is much greater. As well, cuts
in health-care dollars have meant many Canadian hospitals have not been
renovated, making it more difficult to ensure sanitary conditions, he
said, noting that in some Quebec hospitals, there can be 40 patients on a
ward sharing one or two bathrooms. "The
result is that in some of these old buildings, the sanitary conditions are
intolerable. I mean, it's indecent." Pepin, noting
that treating a single patient with C. difficile costs about $10,000, said
funding is needed from the province to improve hospital infrastructure so
the infection can be better controlled. But he also believes Ottawa must
take a role as it did in helping to combat the SARS outbreaks last year
that killed 44 Canadians - far fewer than have died from C. difficile. "I think
what would be needed at the federal level would be some research to look
at better treatments and better infection-control measures," he said.
"There is certainly a possibility that it might spread outside of
Quebec. The potential for transmission is there." While it is not
mandatory to report cases of C. difficile to government agencies, Health
Canada is helping to fund a study to determine how pervasive the disease
has become in Canada. Dr. Andrew
Simor, head of microbiology at Sunnybrook and Women's College Health
Sciences Centre, said the Toronto hospital is among about 20 or 25 across
the country that will be taking part in the study beginning this fall. A surveillance
of C. difficile in 20 Canadian hospitals was done in 1997, said Simor, an
infectious disease specialist. "But in view of the recent reports
from Quebec and Montreal, as well as from other parts of the world, of
increasing Clostridium difficile infection rates and also what appears to
be an increasing severity of the disease, we thought it would be very
important to repeat our previous study to see if there has been a change
and what parts of the country are involved." Besides the
possibility of a more virulent strain, overuse of antibiotics in general
and the two used specifically to treat C. difficile - metronidazole and
vancomycin - may have contributed to strains that are also becoming
drug-resistant, doctors say. Until
researchers can produce more effective treatments or a vaccine against the
C. difficile toxin, the best strategy for controlling the disease in
hospitals is strict infection-control measures - washing hands, using
gloves and gowns, and maintaining sanitation - coupled with appropriate
use of antibiotics, Simor said. "I think
all hospitals across the country need to be prepared for larger outbreaks
caused by this organism and more severe disease," he said. "One
thing we've learned about the spread of infectious disease is that none of
us live in a protected, isolated environment. "So a problem that appears in another country in the world or in a certain part of Canada, it's likely to be on our own doorstep sooner or later."
|